11 Angel Investing Lessons

In the words of Charlie Munger, investing requires a latticework of mental models. Here are 11 lessons to begin filling out your angel investing lattice:

  1. If you can’t decide, the answer is no
  2. Proprietary dealfow means ‘they want you’
  3. Investing takes years to learn, and longer to see returns
  4. Valuation matters
  5. Back $0B companies
  6. Judgment is important but overrated
  7. Invest only in technology
  8. Some of the best investors have no opinions
  9. Incentives make for bad advice
  10. Play fantasy football
  11. Power beats contracts

Details follow. Apply to Spearhead by Jan 26 to learn more about angel investing and get up to $1M to invest.

1. If you can’t decide, the answer is no

If you can’t decide on an investment, the answer is no. For practical purposes, there are an infinite number of investments out there, so pass.

That doesn’t mean you won’t regret it. But the next investment is just as good a priori.

Also, your experience and judgement is only going to get better by the time you see the next deal.

2. Proprietary dealflow means “they want you”

Nobody thinks they have a shortage of dealflow. The hard problem is getting your money into the startups you want. That means the company wants you over other investors. Without “‘they want you,” you will get cut out of good investments and end up with adverse selection of weaker companies. It’s okay to pass on investments, but you don’t want them to pass on you.

Missing out on a few investments can mean losing all your money because of the power law returns of investing. The top deal in a good portfolio of N investments returns as much as deals 2 through N combined. The 2nd best deal returns as much as deals 3 through N combined. If you miss out on the top deal because they didn’t think you were good enough, you’re going to miss out on most of your returns.

You never want to hear, “I will come to you if I don’t get money from Sequoia.”

3. Investing takes years to learn, and longer to see returns

Get started with angel investing now. It takes years to learn and longer to see returns. You want to invest in 30 companies at a minimum–that takes time.

You will start with small investments because your later ones will get better as you gain expertise and brand. That means your returns will take even longer.

It takes a long time to learn, but investing is one of the few professions where you can improve until the day you die.

4. Valuation matters

Valuations for pre-traction companies between 2005-2010 were $1-5M pre-money for the first non-friends-and-family round. Funds that invested during this time period made 4x-100x returns.

These valuations moved to $4-6M pre-money after 2010, with some demo days in the $8-10M range. This likely cut returns by 2/3 or more.

You can’t build a portfolio of pre-traction investments at $8-10M pre-money and expect to make a venture return. On occasion, you can make an exception, but you can’t do all of your investments at this price.

You will have to pass on great teams because the valuation is too high. You will have to pass on future iconic technology companies because the price is too high. But passing on a future iconic company at a $40M pre-money gives you the capital to take 10 shots on goal with unknown companies at $4M pre-money.

You can’t negotiate valuation unless you’re putting in one-third to one-half of the round. Or you’re the first check into the company. In this case, say “I like you but I can’t make the valuation work, but I would invest if the valuation were X.”

Despite high valuations, it’s still possible to make money in angel investing. If you can’t make money in tech, you can’t make money anywhere.

5. Back $0B companies

To quote Vinod Khosla, invest in “$0B companies that are worth $0B today but could be worth $1B tomorrow. Focus your attention only on companies with the potential for a 100-1000x return. Otherwise, pass.

Without these large exits, your portfolio will not achieve a venture return.

6. Judgment is important but overrated

Some markets are obviously bad and should be avoided. But judgment about markets is less important than you think, because there is so much luck and randomness involved. For example, companies can do hard pivots into new markets like Twitter, Slack and Instagram.

Judgment is not about doing a lot of research, digging and homework. By the time you figure it out, you will have missed the deal.

Instead, learn a few markets really well. Of course you will learn about new markets over time. But learn a few markets really well.

Buy all the products and try them. Find the best scientists in the market and invest in them. They can help you with research on your next set of investments. This is an unfair advantage.

You can’t read about new markets unless you’re reading research papers. Waiting to learn new markets by reading about it on TechCrunch is too slow. Start with research papers and then call the grad students who wrote them.

7. Invest only in technology

The best returns come from investing in technology companies. Avoid companies that don’t develop meaningful technology (either software or hardware).

The 5 largest companies in the S&P 500 (Apple, Google, Microsoft, Amazon, and Facebook) are all technology companies. The largest private companies are also technology companies.

There are exceptions like Dollar Shave Club. Their early investors had good returns. But you should only invest in technology as a rule of thumb.

8. Some of the best investors have no opinions

“I have no idea what’s hot. But I’m certainly always listening. Big Dumbo ears. Just listening.” – Doug Leone, Sequoia

Some of the best investors on the planet have no strong opinions about a particular business. They try not to project into the future, so they can listen intently in the present.

Almost any entrepreneur will be smarter in their market than an investor. The investor’s job is to listen and have intuition about whether the founders are smart, honest, and hard-working.

These investors don’t fall in love with the business. When it comes time to do a new round, they re-evaluate the business from scratch and ignore sunk costs.

If you’re thinking about all the great things you could do if you were running the business, you’re going down the wrong path. You’re not running the business.

If you are telling the entrepreneur what to do, don’t invest. Thinking like an investor is different than thinking like an entrepreneur who is determined to make a business work.

9. Incentives make for bad advice

Incentives influence the advice you get from VCs, lawyers, incubators, and us. Everyone serves their own interests first. The best source for angel investing advice is other angels and founders.

People are generally well-meaning but, in the worlds of Upton Sinclair, “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!”

10. Play fantasy football

Build your instincts by looking at startups without investing. This will build up your instincts, which are what you use to make investment decisions. And you need a lot of data to build up your instincts.

In the old days, you had to work at a VC firm to see dealflow. You had to make a few investments and lose money before getting good judgment. John Doerr famously called this “crashing a fighter jet.“  First you lose $25M, then you have some judgment.

Now you can get judgment without crashing the fighter jet. You can see dealflow from your friends, your incubator, demo days, and AngelList. Write down what you like and dislike about each deal and see how your judgment develops over time.

11. Power beats contracts

Contracts can be renegotiated. You will be pressured to renegotiate your investment if you don’t understand power.

Contracts are written for worst-case scenarios, so people can’t outright steal your money. You’re not going to sue someone over a contract because suing people is bad for your dealflow. Real-world decisions are usually based on power.

If you’re the only seed investor in a round, you can get screwed. There aren’t enough co-investors to make a ruckus if the company wants to:

  • Recap the company and start over
  • Raise the cap on your convertible note
  • Give your pro rata to a new investor

If you’re alone, you don’t have the power to fight back. The startup and their new investors can pressure you to renegotiate. So don’t be a herd animal when making an investment decision, but move with a pack when you do.

Apply to Spearhead

Apply to Spearhead by Jan 26 to learn the craft of angel investing, get up to $1M to invest, build a network of angel-founders, and get mentorship from top angels like Yanda Erlich, Tom McInerney, Elad Gil, and Naval Ravikant.

11 Angel Investing Lessons

Introducing Spearhead to fund new angel investors

Founders backing founders in angel investing through Spearhead

Today we’re announcing Spearhead, a program to fund and mentor new angel investors. Spearhead backs founders with a $200K fund so they can start angel investing.

Founders also receive mentorship, including monthly masterclasses from top angel investors and VCs. If they make promising investments, founders receive up to $1M to invest over 2 years.

Apply by January 26 to join the first cohort.

Founders backing founders

Founders are some of the most helpful startup advisors. They help new companies with startup experience and technical expertise. Wealthy founders have been investing in startups since the dawn of venture capital. But most founders don’t have capital to invest.

Spearhead backs founders so they can help startups with advice and money. This lets startups raise money from their most helpful advisors. It compensates founders for their advice. And it creates more high-quality opportunities for downstream VCs.

Learning the craft of angel investing

Angel investing is a skill that founders can practice for the rest of their lives. Spearhead demystifies this skill with mentorship and programming.

Founders will learn how to size up markets and startups quickly. They’ll learn when to pass because the valuation is high. They’ll learn the pitfalls of bridge rounds. They’ll learn the value of pro ratas. They’ll learn when co-investors are providing signal and when they’re not.

Founders will leave the program with refined investment instincts. They’ll also become better founders by working with other top founders in their cohort.

Mentors include angel investors and VCs like Elad Gil, Salil Deshpande, and Yanda Erlich as well as the Spearhead team.

AN Accomplice and AngelList Collaboration

Spearhead is a collaboration between the venture capital firm Accomplice and AngelList. AngelList provides the technology and back office (lawyers, accountants, et cetera). Accomplice is the largest investor in Spearhead. Investments don’t require Accomplice’s approval and founders are encourage to get additional investors for their fund.

The team includes Jeff Fagnan and Cack Wilhelm from Accomplice as well as Naval Ravikant and Jake Zeller from AngelList.

Jeff Fagnan from Accomplice was the first institutional investor in AngelList and has over 15 successful exits. Naval Ravikant is a co-founder of AngelList and angel investor in Uber, Twitter, and Yammer.

We started Spearhead because the growth in new startups requires new investors to help them flourish. We hope these new investors will also make angel investing a little more meritocratic and inclusive, not merely for the wealthy.

Learn more about Spearhead. Apply by January 26.

Introducing Spearhead to fund new angel investors